Welcome to DABS Website

DABS
 
GO BACK

Project Implementation and Supervision Consultant G 0374/0375-AFG (North-South Power Transmission Enhancement Project)


 
Description Project Implementation and Supervision Consultant G 0374/0375-AFG (North-South Power Transmission Enhancement Project)
Attachments ff71b5bbaee897c4def98f4f4600397d.pdf
Publish Date 2016-07-05
Details

Summary of Technical and Commercial Evaluation

of

Project Implementation and Supervision Consultant

G 0374/0375-AFG (North-South Power Transmission Enhancement Project)

 

 

On 20 March 2014, Consulting Services Recruitment Notice (CSRN) was published on ADB Consultant Management System (CMS) website.

a request to submit EOIs for the project. Upon deadline of EOI submission on 12 May 2014, the following EOIs were received, evaluation points that each EOI has received is indicated in the table below:

 

Rank

Point

Firm

Country

1

80.1

SMEC International Pty Ltd.

Australia

2

74.8

SM Developers

India

3

70.8

Pakistan Engineering Services Pvt. Ltd.

Pakistan

4

69.8

INCOSA INC GROUP

Spain

5

66.7

Byucksan Power Co. Ltd.

Korea, Republic of

6

61.2

Indus Associated Consultants (Pvt) Ltd.

Pakistan

7

61.1

VisionRI Connexion Services Private Limited

India

8

60.5

Unint Pro

USA

9

60.3

GFA Consulting Ltd.

Afghanistan

10

60.2

Unicon (UK) Limited

United Kingdome

11

60.2

e.Gen Consultants Ltd.

Bangladesh

12

58.1

Advanced Engineering Associates International

USA

13

57.9

Hill International N.V

Netherland

14

50.1

Societe Generale de Surveillance SA

Switzerland

15

48.5

OMIC Tashkent LLC

Uzbekistan

16

44.2

Environment And Resources Management Consultant

Nepal

17

37.5

RTS Global Consulting LLC

USA

18

37.0

Islamic Countries Business Council

Pakistan

 

The selection method has been announced as quality and cost based selection (QCBS). After evaluation of EOIs, the six consultants who obtained high EOI scores were shortlisted for further process:

After approval of long list to shortlist report, The RFP was sent to all shortlisted consultants on 01 March 2015, calling for full technical and financial proposals. Upon proposal submission deadline on 18 May 2015, the following consultants submitted their technical and financial proposals. The financial proposals remained sealed and unopened:

 

No.

Firm Name

Country of Origin

1

SMEC International Pty. Ltd.

Australia

2

SM Developers

India

3

INCOSA INC GROUP

Spain

4

Byucksan Power Co. Ltd.

Korea, Republic of

5

Indus Associated Consultants (Pvt) Ltd.

Pakistan

 

 

After the evaluation of Technical Proposals, each technical proposal was scored against categories already defined in the RFP, such as, consultant’s qualification, approach and methodology and proposed International and National key experts, table below indicates technical points that each proposal has received:

 

No.

Firm Name

Country of Origin

Technical Score

1

SMEC International Pty. Ltd.

Australia

855

2

SM Developers

India

804.88

3

INCOSA INC GROUP

Spain

784.12

4

Byucksan Power Co. Ltd.

Korea, Republic of

872.52

5

Indus Associated Consultants (Pvt) Ltd.

Pakistan

792.69

 

After Technical Evaluation Report has been approved, the price opening took place on 10 October 2015, and the prices of the five consulting firms were recorded:

 

No.

Firm Name

Country of Origin

Price at Opening (US$ Equivalent)

1

SMEC International Pty. Ltd.

Australia

5,524,600

2

SM Developers

India

4,881,004

3

INCOSA INC GROUP

Spain

5,531,190

4

Byucksan Power Co. Ltd.

Korea, Republic of

5,533,242

5

Indus Associated Consultants (Pvt) Ltd.

Pakistan

5,231,200

 

In the commercial evaluation, the prices have been adjusted due to arithmetical corrections, adjustment due to missing or reduced/increased items, the adjusted price for each proposal is determined:

 

No.

Firm Name

Adjusted Price (US$ Equivalent)

Price Score

1

SMEC International Pty. Ltd.

5,524,600

87.46

2

SM Developers

4,907,234

100.00

3

INCOSA INC GROUP

5,548,590

87.04

4

Byucksan Power Co. Ltd.

5,534,433

87.29

5

Indus Associated Consultants (Pvt) Ltd.

5,252,320

92.58

 

Quality Cost ratio as described in the RFP is (technical: 0.9, price: 0.1), technical and price points and total evaluated points for each proposal is illustrated in the table below:

 

No.

Firm Name

Technical Points

Price Points

Total Points

Ranking

a

b

c = 0.9 x tech. score

d = 0.1 x price score

e = 3+4

f

1

SMEC International Pty. Ltd.

769.50

87.46

856.96

2

2

SM Developers

724.39

100.00

824.39

3

3

INCOSA INC GROUP

705.71

87.04

792.75

5

4

Byucksan Power Co. Ltd.

785.27

87.29

872.56

1

5

Indus Associated Consultants (Pvt) Ltd.

713.42

92.58

806.00

4